Which disaster in Lisbon prompted Voltaire in 1755 to sharply challenge the idea that everything that happens is good?
Voltaire was responding to the Lisbon earthquake of November 1, 1755. The tremors were followed by a tsunami and fires. The disaster claimed many lives and sparked debates far beyond the city about nature, providence, and human suffering. In his poem on the destruction of Lisbon, Voltaire challenged the comforting assertion that all events must already be good exactly as they occur. The subject also appears in his letters and later in Candide. This does not mean that he supplied a modern earth science explanation of the disaster. His focus was on the philosophical and moral consequences of suffering. The alternatives also describe possible natural hazards, but they did not trigger this particular debate. The answer image offers a restrained, imaginative depiction of the destruction without showing casualties.


