How did many pirate crews choose their captain in the early 18th century?
Many pirate crews elected their captain by a vote. The position therefore did not have to be inherited or automatically go to the oldest sailor. If a captain lost the crew’s confidence, they could also remove him. The word “many” matters: pirate crews did not all organize themselves alike, and captains did not all come to power in the same way. Life aboard was also often governed by agreed rules. These ship’s articles could specify how plunder was divided, what punishments applied to rule-breaking, and what compensation injured crew members received. The crew was therefore far from just a group obliged to obey every command of an unrestricted ruler. This participation did not, however, make piracy peaceful or fair toward outsiders. It regulated cooperation within a crew whose attacks harmed other people. The image of a completely lawless pirate ship is therefore just as misleading as the romantic idea of pirates as just heroes.


