Which character is the only one who does not sing in Hildegard of Bingen’s medieval musical drama Ordo virtutum?
The Devil has a speaking role in Ordo virtutum: while the other characters sing, his words have no melody. In the surviving manuscript, his lines have no musical notation. This distinction is part of the work’s design and does not indicate a lost vocal part. The drama centers on the human Soul, who is tempted by the Devil and ultimately returns to the Virtues with their help. Virtues such as Humility and Hope appear as characters. An inner struggle between temptation and good conduct is thus brought to the stage. The contrast between singing and speech has a religious meaning. In Hildegard’s view, music belongs to the praise of God and heavenly harmony. The Devil stands outside this order. His exclusion from music makes that role audible: this is the symbolism of her musical drama, rather than a verifiable claim about supernatural beings.


